Caitlin's Way, on Nickelodeon (USA) / YTV (Canada)
IMDb; Nickipedia; Retro Junk; TV.com; TV Tango; TV Tropes; Unofficial Web Site; Wikipedia

There's this girl named Caitlin Seeger (Lindsay Felton). She's from Philly, but she got shipped around to various foster homes or something, I guess, cuz her mom was dead and her dad was just gone. And she was all cynical and stuff, and gets into trouble, and finally gets sent to High River, Colorado, to live with these relatives she never knew she had. Dori and Jim Lowe (the local vet and sheriff, respectively), and their son Griffen. (Dori was played by Cynthia Belliveau, whom I knew from E.N.G.) And it's all rural and Caitlin doesn't like it there. All she really likes is photography, but she gets a horse named Bandit, and she likes him. And she eventually starts getting used to her new family, I guess, but never completely. Anyway, I think she's pretty cool. I wish I could remember the show better to tell you more about it, but... it never really was that important to me, I guess, except for the main character....